Today is the first day of spring, so it was a bit of a shock to peer outside my window upon awakening, and find that everything was covered in white melting snowfall...which promptly crystalized into heavy ice even before my coffee was brewed. Outside the porch, this early blooming witch hazel dispersed divine perfume even so!
Well, I'll dive in here first and say that Steven Rosenbaum doesn't describe me in the least, and I find him insulting, condescending and typically exploitative. You and your kind will not define me, Steven, no matter how hard you try.
ReplyDeleteI only visit a handful of sites on the internet, but not for the reasons he states. I don't visit "aggregators" like Huffington Post, Daily Kos, Democratic Underground and the countless other holding pens that are out there. I believe they exist to shape public opinion and perception. They are highly censored, replete with forum border collies who patrol the boards to keep the sheep in line.
I come to places like Wit's End because you dare to speak your mind and challenge the prevailing wisdom. You say what you think, unashamedly, and you dare to think outside of the box. Sure, you may be wrong sometimes, but you are willing to admit it and correct your thinking accordingly. Your goal is to understand what is going on around you, and you realize that the conventional, orthodox answers are inadequate and misleading.
Although you don't have many comments, I visit a couple of other sites that have considerable comments that are not censored. I get as much from these comments as I do from the post that engendered them, and I appreciate that....people thinking freely and sharing their unique, or not unique, perspectives and perceptions. It's the best way to learn and expand your own perspective and perception....by entertaining the observations, views and ideas of others. It's like having an infinite number of eyes and ears.....and yet so many want to block it all out and have their daily pablum served to them in a nice tidy manner without all the "noise."
The "noise" is the good stuff. The "noise" is the substance. The other is the pith. I'm sure the folks over at Climate Progress, or whatever it's called, consider you "noise," Gail. I would agree.....and I love it. Bring on the NOISE.
The intertubes are evolving very quickly. I used to feel just as you describe about the comments at CP - especially when I first became aware of the existential threats from climate change, peak everything, and ecosystem collapse, I learned so much from the commenters there and in fact I am extremely fortunate and grateful to have since met several of them, on the east and west coasts, and made fast and noisy friends of them.
ReplyDeleteHowever, we all have gradually come to now consider ourselves the outsiders at CP and our comments either stop the conversation or are frequently ignored. I think that what began as a relatively restrained discussion about science and policy has, in the past two years, given way to astonished alarm as events in the real world have demonstrated mercilessly that the IPCC predictions are far, far too conservative. It would appear only a very few people have the capacity to follow this to its inevitable and inescapable conclusions, awful as they are - and so most are hand-wringers, paralyzed with disbelief, who continue to hope we are going to be able to stop this train wreck with some miraculous techno fix or international agreement.
Like the video yesterday over at DOT! The juxtaposition of WWIII with space travel is ludicrous and yet people convince themselves there is some escape.
I agree with you completely about sites like HuffPo, which are nothing but pure propaganda. To recognize how totally information is controlled leads to what I call living in a parallel universe - or a waking nightmare, depending on how surreal it feels at any given moment!
Then I get emails with links to really far-out theories, and sometimes I hardly know what to think. Try this one - http://www.raven1.net/moret.pdf about depleted uranium. This woman has been warning about a Japanese meltdown for years.
Thanks as always for your comments. Morocco Bama. I really appreciate your thoughts and ideas.
Gail, I found this article by a former physics professor interesting. There's a baby, or two, in his bathwater that I won't throw out, but he provides a scientific rebuttal to anthropogenic climate change that should be answered scientifically, and non-dismissively, by climate scientists who assert anthropogenic climate change is a reality. Maybe you can submit it over at Climate Progress for review and commentary.
ReplyDeletehttp://activistteacher.blogspot.com/2011/03/on-gargantuan-lie-of-climate-change.html
I do agree with him in the sense that anthropogenic climate change has been corporately, and institutionally co-opted and exploited and no good can come from that. As he says:
Environmental scientists and government agencies get funding to study and monitor problems that do not threaten corporate and financial interests. It is therefore no surprise that they would attack continental-scale devastation from resource extraction via the CO2 back door. The main drawback with this strategy is that you cannot control a hungry monster by asking it not to shit as much. ... All in all, the best way to not pollute and destroy the environment is to not pollute and destroy the environment. The best way to not exploit others is to not exploit others.....
It’s about exploitation, oppression, racism, power, and greed. Economic, human, and animal justice brings economic sustainability which in turn is always based on renewable practices. Recognizing the basic rights of native people automatically moderates resource extraction and preserves natural habitats. Not permitting imperialist wars and interventions automatically quenches nation-scale exploitation. True democratic control over monetary policy goes a long way in removing debt-based extortion.
Again, I'm not defending his denial, but he raises some valid questions that should be answered and some of his points, which I have highlighted, have merit.
You have the best collection of photos.. maybe it is time for a gallery/showcase/contest of AGW images. Wait.. you do that already, it just needs a name and an award.
ReplyDelete