Even Hansen is over-reacting to these e-mails, in my opinion.
This is deliberate output of a paid network of climate deniers, deliberately out to screw up the Copenhagen talks.
The real story here is that this cherry picked information from years of correspondence probably did not come from an unassisted private hacker.
A private hacker would have had to comb through years worth of email files to find these apparently damning quotes. The software that the intelligence agencies use to monitor email traffic could have done this in a few minutes, maybe in a few seconds.
So, this appears to me to likely be information from an intelligence service, likely leaked in collusion with the paid denier network funded ultimately by the fossil fuel industries.
The size of this network is much larger than direct funding from ExxonMobil would suggest.
From the Union of Concerned Scientists report from 2007:
Smoke, Mirrors & Hot Air
How ExxonMobil uses Big Tobacco’s Tactics to Manufacture Uncertainty on Climate Science
In 2005, the end use combustion of ExxonMobil’s products—gasoline, heating oil, kerosene, diesel products, aviation fuels, and heavy fuels—resulted in 1,047 million
metric tons of carbon dioxide–equivalent emissions.
If it was a country, ExxonMobil would rank sixth in emissions...For example, the George C. Marshall Institute, a leading paid climate denier think tank, has received six hundred thousand dollars directly from ExxonMobil.
But they have received something over six million dollars from a network of conservative foundations including the Scaife and Bradley foundations. This network of conservative foundations often funds the same organizations that ExxonMobil does, including the Heritage Foundation, the American Enterprise Institute, and other leading denier organizations:
Funding for the George C. Marshall Institute:
Exxon Mobil Corporation $640,000
Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation $3,590,303
Sarah Scaife Foundation $2,785,000
Funding for the American Enterprise Institute:
Exxon Mobil Corporation $1,625,000
Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation $~17,000,000
Scaife Foundations $~8,000,000
Funding for the Heritage Foundation:
Exxon Mobil Corporation $460,000
Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation $~14,000,000
Scaife Foundations $~24,000,000
To see that this network of conservative “charitable” foundations often fund climate denier think tanks in an apparently coordinated manner, go to the Media Matters Action Network, and do a few searches on this list of ExxonMobil funded think tanks in the Union of Concerned Scientists report:
American Council for Capital Formation, Center for Policy Research
American Council on Science and Health
American Enterprise Institute
American Friends of the Institute of Economic Affairs
American Legislative Exchange Council
Annapolis Center for Science-Based Public Policy
Arizona State University, Office of Climatology
Atlantic Legal Foundation
Atlas Economic Research Foundation
Center for the Defense of Free Enterprise
Centre for the New Europe
Center for the Study of Carbon Dioxide and Global Change
Citizens for a Sound Economy Educational Foundation [became FreedomWorks]
Committee for a Constructive Tomorrow
Competitive Enterprise Institute
Congress of Racial Equality (CORE)
Consumer Alert, Inc.
Federalist Society for Law & Public Policy Studies
Foundation for Research on Economics and the Environment
Free Enterprise Action Institute
Frontiers of Freedom Institute
George C. Marshall Institute
Hoover Institution on War, Revolution, and Peace, Stanford University
Institute for Energy Research
International Policy Network
Media Research Center
Mercatus Center, George Mason University
National Association of Neighborhoods
National Center for Policy Analysis
National Center for Public Policy Research
National Environmental Policy Institute
Pacific Research Institute for Public Policy
Science and Environmental Policy Project
The Advancement of Sound Science Center, Inc.
Tech Central Station
Weidenbaum Center, Washington University (formerly Center for the Study
of American Business)
In essentially all of their public statements, ExxonMobil is lying, in my opinion.
They are funding a network of information laundering sites, and are doing so in concert with a much larger network of “charitable” foundations that support conservative causes including the opposition of climate change.
This conservative “charitable: foundation network is a much larger, and much better funded network, as a few searches on Media Action Network shows – and it funds global warming denier information laundering sites in concert with ExxonMobil.
The CIA are scum, pure and simple. However, that's not saying much I suppose, since there's so much scum these days. Maybe there always was, and I'm just increasingly sensitive to it. Either way, it's still a lot of scum.ReplyDelete
I can read a story like this one, over at Desdemona Despair, about how the entire sea is going to become anoxic...or, I can watch the latest Greenman video about methane escaping from the Russian permafrost, and how it's TOO LATE to deter...then again, I could just scroll through the open thread at Climate Progress and ruminate on apocalyptic warnings like this one:
So many possible ways for this all to end badly. I considered starting a betting pool, but then I remembered that I'm not a gambler, and it's a bet that you can never collect on. It's nice to have options, though, isn't it? It's a smorgasbord of delightfully horrific ways to perish.
It's not too late! We DO have an active wager, at the very end of this post.
I encourage you and any other readers to place bets, it's not expensive!
But it will keep us all engaged in the debate.
Those links don't work for me, Morocco Bama.ReplyDelete
I can go to the website, but not exactly the posts you linked to.
Not sure why? But I would like to real them!
Here you go, Gail, try this one. It's the second and third article on that page. I stay away from the 911 stuff....it's a never-ending rabbit hole that goes nowhere, so if you feel the same, ignore the first article.ReplyDelete
Thank you all, and please go to Catman's youtube list http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=F021912A3436BA08 when you need a little song...I do!ReplyDelete